Automatic Pour Over Coffee Makers – Which One Is For You?

I understand you may not have the time to read the entire article, therefore we think the best automatic pour over coffee maker is the Cuisinart DCC-4000.

The time has come to get yourself an coffee maker. Maybe you’re thinking of getting one for the first time, or maybe you’re replacing your old one. 

Whatever the reason, this review of the best automatic pour over coffee makers will help you narrow down which one is right for you.

These are the five products we’ll be looking at:

Firstly, we’ll cover what it is you should be considering when choosing a coffee maker. 

Lets jump in.

Isn’t An Automatic Pour Over Coffee Maker The Same An Automatic Drip Coffee Maker?

You may be confused about the difference between an automatic pour over coffee maker and an automatic drip coffee maker. They’re pretty much the same, the only differences come with how the water is dispensed and how the temperature controlled.

Firstly, I’ll explain quickly how the drip coffee maker works. You have a basket lined with filter paper where the ground coffee sits. You take boiling water and pour it into the basket where it slowly filters through, extracting flavour compounds on its way.

It’s a very common way of brewing a coffee, but because the coffee grounds get flooded and the water temperature starts to cool during the process, it can lead to a poor extraction.

This is where an automatic pour over coffee maker differs. First of all the water is kept at optimal temperature throughout the extraction, somewhere between 190-200F. In the really good machines, the heated water is kept in a seperate tank to ensure it remains at the right temperature. 

Not only this, but the water is distributed by a shower head very evenly, as opposed to being flooded. An initial, small amount of water is sprayed to let the coffee beans “bloom”. This is the technical term for letting the coffee grounds absorb some of the water, which releases oils and the locked in CO2. The oils are partly responsible for the reason coffee tastes so good.

After the “blooming” has happened, the rest of the water is dispensed to finish off the brewing process. 

cup of coffee with coffee beans and equipment

A Few Of Things To Think About

When deciding what automatic pour over coffee maker you want, there are some things you should be considering. Let’s run through them.

Is It Easy To Clean?

It’s a job none of us really enjoy doing, but it is essential to keeping your coffee smooth and flavourful. If cleaning is easy to do and doesn’t take long, we’re much more likely to do it.

If cleaning is an absolute pain and awkward, we’ll never do it. Whether the parts are dishwasher proof or at least removable should be on your list of things to consider. 

Even if you don’t have a dishwasher, being able to remove the drip tray, coffee basket or water reservoir and place it in the sink to wash is very handy.

Do You Want A Glass Or Thermal Carafe?

There are a couple of differences between the two that you should know about before deciding. A glass carafe is better looking, in my opinion. They’re more elegant and look better sitting on your countertop, however they generally aren’t as good when it comes to practically.

To keep your coffee hot for hours you’ll need a warming plate for the glass carafe to sit on. You’ll have to keep the coffee maker on for this, plus you start to get a burnt taste in your coffee after a while on the warming plate if it’s too hot.

If brewing a carafe and keeping it hot for hours is something you’re looking to get from your coffee maker, go for a thermal carafe. For example if you’re going out for the day, or have a long meeting at work and want hot coffee all day, thermal carafes allow that.

Their number one priority is to keep your coffee hot, and they do it very well. 

How Much Coffee Do You Want To Brew?

Maybe the most important question to ask yourself on the list. There are small 5 cup coffee makers, larger 12 cup coffee makers, or dual coffee makers that brew carafes as well as single servings. 

Maybe your household only drinks a cup or two a day. If that’s the case you don’t need something that can brew 12 cups, unless you still want the option for whzen friends or family come over.

Carefully think about how much coffee you’re going to need as you don’t want to be left short once you’ve bought it.

How Easy Is It To Use?

When you’re talking about automatic coffee makers, user friendliness is high in priority. You can normally press a button and your coffee is on its way, sometimes you can choose between a few options but it’s never overly complicated.

If you’re someone who just wants to wake up to a coffee each morning, then these automatic coffee makers are your perfect match. 

Is It Programmable?

This is a great feature. I’d personally love to own a coffee maker with a built in timer. Basically, you can set your coffee maker to start brewing coffee at a certain time 24 hours into the future.

So for example, it’s 9pm and you’re heading off to bed. Prepare your coffee maker with the coffee grind and set the timer for when your alarm is meant to go off. By the time you’ve gotten out of bed and are downstairs there should be a fresh carafe of coffee waiting for you.

If there is one thing that’s going to get you out of bed on a morning, it’s the fact that there’s coffee being made for you. Automatically. By a robot coffee maker machine. 

How Durable Is It?

How long is it going to last before you have to buy another coffee maker? These things can be expensive so you want one that’s going to stand the test of time. 

Before we buy, we can normally measure how good the quality of the build is by looking at the warranty. As a general rule of thumb, the longer the warranty the better the build

Some brands offer up to a five year warranty, some one year. It’s certainly worth finding out before you buy, as if there is a manufacturing fault you want to know you’re covered.

Coffee beans in coffee sack

Best Automatic Pour Over Coffee Maker – The Reviews

So, now you know exactly what you’re looking for, let’s dive into the products.

Cuisinart DCC-4000 

best automatic pour over coffee maker

Key features:

  • 12 cup capacity
  • Glass carafe
  • 24 hour programmable
  • Regular or bold flavour settings
  • Self clean
  • 1-4 cup brew setting
  • Auto off (can set to turn off between 0-4 hours after last brew)
  • Brew pause feature
  • 14.5 x 8.26 x 14.6 inches (W x D x H)
  • 7.9 pounds
  • 3 year warranty

We’re kicking off the reviews with a strong contender. The Cuisinart comes with a generous 3 year warranty which tells me they believe in the quality of their product. When looking at the build quality it’s clear to see they haven’t used cheap plastic that seems like it could break.

The ‘brew pause’ feature means you can sneak a quick cup before the carafe has finished fully brewing. Some of us get a little impatient for our first coffee of the day, especially when you’re watching the carafe slowly fill up. With this feature, you can pause the brewing process and pour yourself a cup as soon as it’s ready, then replace the carafe and finish brewing. 

A feature that isn’t too common is the self-clean function. The Cuisinart is so easy to clean because of this, which is important for keeping your coffee smooth and full of flavour. It’s also easy to notice if anything is getting a little dirty due to almost everything being glass.

The coffee comes out hot, flavourful and in a reasonable time. It’s kept warm by the warming plate which has three settings to choose from, helping to stop the burnt taste if it’s too hot. Good quality build with even better quality coffee.

>>Check price on amazon<<

Redline MK1 Coffee Brewer

best automatic pour over coffee maker

Key features:

  • 8 cup brew capacity
  • Glass carafe
  • Fast brewing cycle making a full carafe in 6 minutes
  • ‘Pre-infusion’ mode to allow coffee to bloom
  • Brew pause feature
  • 14.6 x 13.7 x 7.8 inches
  • 7.1 pounds 
  • 2 year warranty

The Redline pour over coffee maker is a sleek and simple but sophisticated design means it’s a pleasure to have sitting on the countertop. The font they use for the logo looks like something from a 50’s muscle car, giving it a kind of retro look

The “Parking Brake” feature is unique and tells me they’ve thought a lot about the little details that affect our daily coffee making experiences. It allows you to pause the brew, but is also really good at stopping any drips from falling onto the hot plate below, stopping the smell of burnt coffee and keeping it clean

The last thing you want to be smelling when making a cuppa, is burnt coffee. So this is a little detail I really like.

The quality of coffee is superb, especially if you’re grinding the coffee beans up yourself. I think their pre-infusion process to allow the beans to “bloom” is very effective, as well as the temperature it retains while brewing. You can choose how much coffee you want to brew by putting the desired amount of water in the reservoir.

The carafe, although excellently designed to not leak in the slightest, is unique in size. This may sound good, but break it and you’ll have no choice in a replacement as you’ll have to go directly through Redline.

Overall, a really elegant looking machine that brews really great coffee.

>>Check price on amazon<<

Bonavita BV1900TS

best automatic pour over coffee maker

Key features

  • 8 cup carafe capacity
  • Thermal carafe 
  • Carafe lid, filter basket, and showerhead are dishwasher safe
  • Flat bottomed filter basket
  • BPA plastic free
  • Powerful 1500-watt heater to maintain temperature precisely
  • 12.4 x 6.8 x 12.2 inches
  • 6.13 pounds
  • 2 year warranty

Firstly, the Bonavita comes with a thermal carafe meaning its shatter resistant, durable and some parts of it like the lid can be thrown in the dishwasher. If you’re prone to smashing things or have a busy morning routine and don’t have time to wash up, then a thermal carafe that’s dishwasher safe is going to be good for you.

With that being said, this carafe isn’t spill proof. The pouring spout isn’t very well designed. Maybe I’m nitpicking here but it is annoying having drips of coffee on the table whenever you pour yourself a brew.

The fact the filter basket is flat bottomed means the ground coffee can be evenly saturated, leading to an even extraction. This does wonders for the flavour and to the balance of the coffee.

The Bonavita produces good coffee, there’s no denying it. However there are a couple of little issues to do with the design. For example the electricity cord is only two feet long and to remove the carafe, you have to remove the coffee ground holder and then screw on the lid of the carafe to be able to pour. It’s a little awkward and annoying which I think could have been avoided.

Apart from these little annoyances, it still brews good coffee.

>>Check price on amazon<<

OXO Brew

best automatic pour over coffee maker

Key features:

  • 9 cup capacity carafe
  • Thermal carafe
  • 2-9 cup brew settings
  • Very simple and user friendly
  • Great aesthetics with LED interface
  • 24 hour programmable
  • 15 x 8.3 x 17.2 inches
  • 7.7 pounds
  • 2 year warranty

The OXO has a very modern look, with its LED interface, twisting dial to navigate brewing options and stainless steel carafe. Not only does the twist dial look good, it’s also really easy to navigate the menu with. 

The build quality is spot on. It doesn’t feel like it’s made with that cheap plastic. Plus the parts that need regular cleaning are easily removable making cleaning simple. If the parts ever need replacing, then doing so is straightforward.

No complaints with the coffee either. It’s incredibly consistent with the taste and flavours. I also like you get 10 filters already included in the box to get you started, it’s a nice touch.

There are a couple of cons with the OXO. Firstly there is no hot plate and even though the carafe is thermal, it doesn’t keep your coffee hot for hours and hours like some of the other thermal carafes on the market. The mechanism that stops coffee from dripping onto the hot plate isn’t amazing and so it makes a mess.

>>Check price on amazon<<

Technivorm Moccamaster 59616

best automatic pour over coffee maker

Key features:

  • 8 cup carafe capacity
  • Glass carafe
  • Takes up to 6 minutes to brew a full carafe
  • Automatic shut off after 100 minutes
  • Comes in a huge range of colours
  • 6.5 x 12.75 x 14 inches
  • 6.2 pounds
  • 5 year warranty

Firstly, it needs to be said that it’s quite an expensive machine for an at home coffee maker. When you’re paying more than the average, you expect to get great quality coffee with an easy, simple, user friendly experience. That’s pretty much what you get with the Technivorm.

Being able to choose whether you want the hot plate on or off, high or low, means you don’t get the bottom of the carafe burning up. The Technivorm is a solid build and produces some top quality coffee, while also looking elegant and unique in its design. The 5 year warranty shows that the company believes it’s making a top quality product that will last.

With the hot plate staying on for 100 minutes, that should be plenty of time to drink the carafe on a morning. Even if it isn’t, brewing a fresh carafe takes no time at all and so isn’t a big problem.

There are 28 different colours to choose from, so you can pick a colour that goes with the colour scheme of your kitchen. 

Although a pricey choice compared to some others, you know you’ll be getting a long lasting product that’s making top quality coffee consistently, and in rapid time.

>>Check price on amazon<<

Final Thoughts

Some of the cons I’ve mentioned in these reviews might seem a little petty, but the quality of the coffee makers these days are high. It’s the little things that make a big difference in drinking coffee from home.

With everything considered like coffee quality, build quality, ease of use, cleaning and maintaining, and price, I’d have to pick the Cuisinart DCC-4000. It’s a household name for a reason. They offer a 3 year warranty and their automatic pour over coffee maker is up there with the best.

With the being said, if you have a high budget for your coffee maker, pick the Technivorm Moccamaster. You get what you pay for with the build, coffee quality and aesthetics. 

Which one did you go for? Let us know in the comments!

You’re probably going to need some coffee to go with your coffee maker, so check out some of our reviews.

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest
Share on email
Tom Bolland

Tom Bolland

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Check out some of our other articles